小评《同一首歌 谭咏麟金曲100》！

雷斯里

<p><img src="data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720412287233.jpg" border="0" onload="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onmouseover="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.style.cursor=\'hand\'; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onclick="if(!this.resized) {return true;} else {window.open(\'data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720412287233.jpg\');}" onmousewheel="return imgzoom(this);" alt="" /><br/><img src="data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720413373272.jpg" border="0" onload="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onmouseover="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.style.cursor=\'hand\'; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onclick="if(!this.resized) {return true;} else {window.open(\'data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720413373272.jpg\');}" onmousewheel="return imgzoom(this);" alt="" /><br/><img src="data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720414118288.jpg" border="0" onload="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onmouseover="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.style.cursor=\'hand\'; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onclick="if(!this.resized) {return true;} else {window.open(\'data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720414118288.jpg\');}" onmousewheel="return imgzoom(this);" alt="" /><br/><img src="data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720415551256.jpg" border="0" onload="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onmouseover="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.style.cursor=\'hand\'; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onclick="if(!this.resized) {return true;} else {window.open(\'data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720415551256.jpg\');}" onmousewheel="return imgzoom(this);" alt="" /><br/><img src="data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/20061172042662665.jpg" border="0" onload="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onmouseover="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.style.cursor=\'hand\'; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onclick="if(!this.resized) {return true;} else {window.open(\'data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/20061172042662665.jpg\');}" onmousewheel="return imgzoom(this);" alt="" /><br/><img src="data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720422349146.jpg" border="0" onload="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onmouseover="if(this.width>screen.width*0.7) {this.resized=true; this.width=screen.width*0.7; this.style.cursor=\'hand\'; this.alt=\'Click here to open new window\nCTRL+Mouse wheel to zoom in/out\';}" onclick="if(!this.resized) {return true;} else {window.open(\'data/attachment/forum/dvbbs/2006-11/200611720422349146.jpg\');}" onmousewheel="return imgzoom(this);" alt="" /><br/></p><p></p><p><br/>&nbsp;</p><p></p><p>《同一首歌 谭咏麟金曲100》</p><p><br/>书分三部分：小传，歌谱，歌曲汇总。<br/>标价25块，其实六折的价格已经可以拿到了。</p><p></p><p><br/>仅仅看到封底就感觉这书应该是本错误百出，编写欠严谨的“大杂烩”，也很可能就是直接从网上拼材料的“合集”。<br/>看完书前的阿伦小传更大失所望，曲谱是否标准还没细究，翻看了几页，歌名词曲作者歌词的笔误就随处可见。<br/>书中穿插了部分歌曲的简单介绍，书后附的歌曲大汇总，也算是亮点。准确率？可想而知。</p><p>其实单“谭咏麟”三字就能激起购买欲望了，内容好与坏可以视而不见，不过是留念而已。</p><p>只是看着此书倍感凄惨．．．</p><p></p><p></p><p><br/></p><p>&nbsp;</p><p></p><p></p><p></p><p></p>

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-11-7 20:42:39编辑过]

神秘天使

<p>这本书如果让小雷写 我觉得一定更好</p>

superman

今天在我们那里的书城看到了扬花先前通知的新书《同一首歌；最爱谭咏麟》，顺便翻了一下，这本书就像一本杂志般大小，翻开封面是一个黑白的《MY。LOVE》CD造型的画面，然后是几页对阿伦历史的简要介绍，估计是从网上摘录整理的，附带几张阿伦近期的小彩色照片，终于到了主内容了，就是对阿伦比较有代表性的歌曲和一些偏歌作了个歌本式的收录，在百分之八，九十的歌曲后面作了个简要的评论，但看得出来有很多评论是摘取了曾经在网上流传的很牛的那部《偏爱》的评论，但也加入了自己的总结等等，书的最后是一个唱片作品的周期表，最后考虑了下，没有什么买头，一、阿伦写真照可以说没有。二、包括编辑都没有认真听歌，摘抄了别人的评论精华。三、这里的歌曲不看歌谱都能唱出何况歌曲还只是登录了小部分歌曲。四、没有赠碟五、歌本有许多错误之处。最后我买了一张温拿的15周年演唱会引进CD。

sdslgl

这么粗制滥造的东西坚决不买！

弹头

靠!!拿ALAN的名誉卖钱,坚决抵制!!!!!!!!

雷斯里

<p>补充了几张图片．．．</p><p>&nbsp;</p>